Teaching Deep Thinking in a World of Instant AI Answers

The image is the cover of the "2026 Student Guide to Artificial Intelligence". The main title is "HUMAN WISDOM FOR THE AGE OF AI" , accompanied by the subtitle "A FIELD GUIDE TO CULTIVATING ESSENTIAL SKILLS".  The central feature is a circular, classical-style illustration showing an ancient bearded scholar in flowing robes standing at a table. He is operating an armillary sphere (an astronomical model) while reaching toward a glowing, geometric polyhedron that floats in the air, emitting beams of light against a starry background.At the bottom of the page, the logos for Elon University, the Imagining the Digital Future Center, AAC&U, and The Princeton Review are displayed. The URL www.studentguidetoai.org is printed in the top left corner.

As we navigate the rapid integration of generative AI into our classrooms, the conversation often centers on policy, detection, or prompt engineering. However, a new resource has just been released that shifts the focus back to the core of what we do: cultivating the human mind.

Published by Elon University, the AAC&U, and The Princeton Review, the 2026 Student Guide to Artificial Intelligence—titled “Human Wisdom for the Age of AI” is the third in a series responding to the global call for higher education to lead the AI revolution.

While titled for students, this resource is a robust pedagogical framework for faculty in any discipline. It argues that as AI becomes more capable, the habits of a liberal education—critical inquiry, ethical reasoning, and creative problem-solving—become more important, not less.

The guide is built on a “profound paradox”: while AI can accelerate discovery and automate repetitive tasks, an overreliance on these tools can lead to passive consumption and the erosion of critical thinking. To counter this, the field guide focuses on 10 fundamental human capacities—such as curiosity, empathy, and ethical reasoning—that remain the “bullseye” of human value in an automated world.

Each section pairs a Great Thinker from history with a Mini-tool designed to help users move beyond “AI blandness”.

Essential Mini-Tools for the Classroom

These hands-on exercises can be easily adapted for any discipline to ensure students (and faculty) remain “the human in charge”:

  • The Idea Compass (Curiosity): Inspired by René Descartes, this tool encourages users to interrogate AI outputs from four directions: first principles, history, related concepts, and practical applications.

  • The Depth Gauge (Deep Work): Using insights from Seneca the Younger, this exercise challenges users to move from “surface skimming” with AI into the “scuba zone” of human-only deep research.

  • The Persuasion Triangle (Communication): Drawing on Aristotle’s Rhetoric, this tool helps students verify that their AI-assisted work still contains Ethos (character) and Pathos (emotion), elements a machine cannot authentically provide.

  • Panning for Gold (Wisdom): A decision-making framework based on Cicero’s virtues, using filters for reality, identity, empathy, and durability to find the “heavy nuggets of value” in AI-generated options.

Actionable Resources for Your Classroom

This is a true field guide, designed for active learning and personal development. Every section includes a “Mini-tool”—like the Idea Compass or the Persuasion Triangle—to help users sharpen specific skills while working with AI.

How to get started:

  1. Download Teacher’s Guides: Every capacity page includes a link to a companion teacher’s guide in PDF or PowerPoint format.

  2. Adapt for Your Discipline: Exercises can be used in any order and adapted by faculty to align with specific course goals and content.

  3. Encourage Self-Assessment: Students can take a 10-question anonymous assessment to reflect on their AI dependency and “human wisdom” score.

You can download the full guide and explore these resources for free at www.studentguidetoAI.org.

Reclaiming the “Human-in-Charge” Zone

Ultimately, this guide serves as a reminder that while AI can process data, it lacks the lived experience and ethical judgment required for true understanding. By bringing these classical perspectives into the digital age, we can help our students move beyond being “button-pushers” and instead become sovereign thinkers who use technology to enhance, rather than replace, their own agency.

What’s Really Real: Teaching Critical Inquiry Through the History of Synthetic Media

In an era of deepfakes and generative AI, the question of “what’s real” has never felt more urgent. But as it turns out, we’ve been grappling with synthetic media for much longer than you might think.

A bright, modern gallery space with wooden pillars and brick accents, featuring an exhibit on the history of synthetic media. In the foreground, a vintage wooden stereoscope and antique cameras sit on a curved white display table alongside black-and-white "spirit photography" from the 19th century. In the background, a large digital screen shows a modern AI-generated face transition, while several people—including a man in a blazer and students—stand nearby, looking at the displays and discussing the evolution of image manipulation.

The University Library is inviting the W&L community to join a special webinar hosted by the Virginia chapter of the Association of College and Research Libraries (VLACRL). This session offers a deep dive into the evolution of “fake” media and provides practical strategies for teaching students how to navigate it.


“What’s Really Real: Strategies for Teaching Critical Inquiry through the History of Synthetic Media”

  • When: Tuesday, March 17, 2026
  • Time: 11:00 AM – 12:15 PM
  • Where: Join via Zoom or attend the public screening in the Leyburn Library Gallery.

Why Attend?

The presenter, Oscar Keyes (Multimedia Teaching & Learning Librarian at VCU), specializes in the intersection of creative technologies and pedagogy. His approach moves beyond just “identifying AI” and looks at the broader history of how we’ve always used technology to alter reality—from 19th-century spirit photography to modern-day generative models.

What will be covered:

  • Historical Parallels: Understanding how previous “emerging technologies” (like the first cameras) challenged our sense of truth.
  • Classroom-Tested Activities: Strategies designed to deepen student understanding of how synthetic images are created.
  • Verification Skills: Practical methods for effectively verifying the authenticity of digital media in a classroom setting.

How to Participate

You have two options for joining the conversation on March 17:

  1. Join the Public Screening: The Library has reserved the Gallery in Leyburn Library for a public showing at 11:00 AM. This is a great opportunity to attend with colleagues and engage in the discussion in person.

  2. Join Virtually: If you can’t make it to Leyburn, you can register to attend virtually via Zoom.

Note: If you cannot attend live but are interested in the content, please register anyway to receive a link to the recording after the event.

Permission to Play: The Professors at Play PlayBook is Now Available for Free!

An illustration of a colorful, hand-drawn octopus with tentacles in shades of red, green, blue, and purple occupies the left side of the image. The right side features a bold red rectangle containing the title "PROFESSORS AT PLAY PLAYBOOK" in white text, followed by the subtitle "Real-world techniques from a more playful higher education classroom". In the top right corner, a small logo reads "PLAY STORY EDITION". At the bottom, the text "EDITED BY LISA FORBES & DAVID THOMAS" is printed in black.

In higher education, there is often a misconception that for learning to be “deep,” it has to be “dry.” The Professors at Play PlayBook is here to challenge that.

Originally published in 2023 via Carnegie Mellon’s etc Press, this incredible collection has already been downloaded nearly 10,000 times, helping educators worldwide reclaim the classroom as a space for curiosity and experimentation.

The PlayBook has recently transitioned to the Play Story Press family. To celebrate this new chapter, the unabridged edition is being shared widely to ensure every educator has access to these transformative strategies.

Why You Should Check Out the PlayBook

Whether you are looking for ways to engage students in a specific discipline, or just curious about “playful pedagogy,” this resource is a goldmine.

  • Practical Techniques: This isn’t just a book of theory. It’s a curated collection of actionable techniques submitted by playful educators from across the globe.
  • Discipline-Agnostic: From STEM to the Humanities, the PlayBook showcases how play can be adapted to any subject matter.
  • Finding “Permission to Play”: One of the biggest hurdles to innovative teaching is feeling like you have the “authority” to try something different. This book provides the inspiration and the evidence to help you find your own permission to play.

Download Your Copy

The PlayBook is a valuable resource for any faculty member—from those brand new to the idea of playful teaching to seasoned pros looking for fresh ideas! Download your FREE copy at https://professorsatplay.org/playbook/.

Registration is now open for the 10-Day AI Bootcamp!

A wide horizontal banner image with a dark blue background featuring glowing circuit board patterns and snowflakes. On the left, a glowing laptop displays a brain icon and a toolbox with gears. Large white and blue text across the center reads: "THE PRE-HOLIDAY POWER-UP: UPGRADE YOUR AI TOOLKIT BEFORE WINTER BREAK (IN JUST 10 MINUTES/DAY!)". On the right, a desk calendar marked "DECEMBER" with a "10 MIN/DAY" timer sits next to a mug of cocoa and a decorated miniature Christmas tree.

Ready for round two of AI skill-building? Join the 10-Day AI Bootcamp: Claude Edition with Sybil Prince Nelson running December 8th-21st alongside Winter Academy.

What’s different from Fall? This bootcamp features Claude instead of ChatGPT, so you’ll explore:

  • Web search and real-time research
  • Document creation (artifacts)
  • Conversational depth and reasoning
  • Different strengths and approaches

Perfect for:

  • Repeaters: Compare Claude vs ChatGPT side-by-side
  • Newcomers: No prior AI experience needed!

The format: 10 minutes a day, 10 weekday prompts + 4 optional weekend bonuses. Earn stars, collect a digital badge at 8+.

Tracks for everyone: Faculty and staff versions of each prompt mean relevant, practical applications for your actual work.

Self-enroll here: https://wlu.instructure.com/enroll/E38KEW

Questions? Email sprincenelson@wlu.edu or stop by PLAI Lab office hours.

Let’s explore what makes Claude different—one prompt at a time!

A Helpful Guide to Writing AI Image Prompts

If you’ve used AI image generators like Gemini, ChatGPT, or Microsoft Copilot, you know that the quality of your result often depends on the quality of your prompt. It can sometimes be tricky to describe exactly what you’re imagining.

To help with this, we’d like to share the Text-to-Image Prompting Quick Guide. It’s a new, simple resource designed to help you build more effective and detailed prompts.

The guide breaks the process down into six key components to consider:

  • Subject
  • Setting
  • Mood & Lighting
  • Style
  • Framing
  • Context

The tool is flexible, whether you have a few minutes or want to learn the fundamentals. You can:

  • 📚 Learn the Framework: Read through each component section to understand the principles.
  • 🛠️ Use the Prompt Builder: Jump straight to the builder to quickly assemble a prompt based on the parts that matter to you.
  • 📊 Track Your Progress: For those interested, there are optional assessments to help you see how your skills improve.

Prompting is an iterative process, and this framework is designed to make that process a little easier. If you’re interested in refining your prompts, you can explore the guide at the link below.

Check out the Text-to-Image Prompting Quick Guide

(This guide also serves as one of my final projects for my graduate portfolio as I complete my master’s in instructional design. A lot of thought went into making it a useful and effective learning resource, and I’m excited to share it.)

Regurgitative AI: Why ChatGPT Won’t Kill Original Thought

A minimalist illustration of a human and a robot collaboratively assembling a light bulb. The human holds the left half of the bulb, while the robot holds the right half, which is shaped like a gear. The image symbolizes the partnership between human creativity and artificial intelligence, set against a bright orange background.

In her compelling new article, Regurgitative AI: Why ChatGPT Won’t Kill Original Thought, Dr. Sybil Prince Nelson explores the nuanced role of generative AI in higher education—challenging the widespread fear that tools like ChatGPT will replace human creativity. Drawing on her dual expertise as both a mathematician and a novelist, Nelson argues that while AI excels at remixing existing ideas, it cannot originate truly novel thought. That distinction, she contends, is where educators and students continue to shine.

Key Highlights:

  • AI as a remix artist: Nelson compares ChatGPT to a DJ like Girl Talk—brilliant at blending familiar tracks into something fresh, yet incapable of composing an original symphony from silence.
  • Limits of AI creativity: Through examples from fiction writing, statistical coding, and even brainstorming sessions, she demonstrates how AI often narrows rather than expands the range of ideas. 
  • Pedagogical strategies: Nelson provides five actionable methods for faculty, including requiring students to document their AI prompts, reflect on tool influence, and redesign assignments to emphasize personal voice, ethical judgment, and iterative thinking—areas AI cannot replicate.
  • Hope for the college essay: Despite AI’s ability to generate polished prose, Nelson affirms that the authentic process of writing—grappling with ideas, revising drafts, and expressing individual perspective—remains irreplaceable.

This thoughtful, research-informed article is a must-read for anyone rethinking assignment design in the age of AI. 

Read the full article on Faculty Focus!

Reimagining Law: How AI Empowers Small Firms

"The Next Generation of Law: AI and Small Firm Practice." It features two robotic hands holding a blue circular emblem with "AI" in the center. The flyer promotes a discussion led by Professor Josh Fairfield and Ben Byrd '08L on how AI is reshaping opportunities for solo practitioners and small law firms. The event is scheduled for Thursday, November 6, 2025, from 1:00 PM to 2:00 PM in Classroom B. The flyer notes that pizza will be served.

Can artificial intelligence level the playing field in legal practice? While Big Law continues to dominate, AI is opening new doors for solo practitioners and small firms to thrive. Join Professor Josh Fairfield and Ben Byrd ’08L for a thought-provoking conversation on how AI is reshaping the legal landscape—what it can do, what it can’t, and what it means for your future.

🗓️ Thursday, November 6, 2025
🕐 1:00 PM – 2:00 PM
📍 Classroom B
🍕 Pizza will be served!

PayPal, Venmo Users Can Get Perplexity Pro, Comet Browser Access for Free

Three smartphone screens display a PayPal promotional offer for Perplexity Pro. The first screen shows a PayPal balance of $200 with a featured offer for one free year of Perplexity Pro when linking PayPal. The middle screen highlights the Perplexity Pro with PayPal promotion, offering 12 free months when users connect a valid billing method. The third screen displays a user’s subscription list, including Perplexity, Music, Cloud Storage, Pet Supplies, and News, with a featured offer for 10% cash back on streaming services for three months.
Credit: PayPal/Perplexity

A new promotion from PayPal and Venmo provides their users with a one-year subscription to Perplexity Pro and access to the Comet AI browser at no cost. The Perplexity Pro plan, which is typically priced at $20 per month or $200 per year, includes unlimited searches, access to advanced AI models, and image generation capabilities.

The offer also includes access to the Comet AI browser, a Chromium-based (same open-source codebase beneath Chrome, Edge and Opera) browser with integrated AI functions. Normally, access to this browser is limited to invitees or subscribers of the Perplexity Max plan.

Comet has several unique features, chief among them a powerful AI assistant you can access at any time. It’s a chatbot that lives inside your web browser and can access the pages you open. (Unsurprisingly, Comet uses Perplexity as its default home page and search engine.)

To receive the offer, users must link their PayPal or Venmo account to Perplexity. This can be done through the PayPal or Venmo mobile apps or on a dedicated page on Perplexity’s website.

The following conditions apply:

  • The offer is valid through December 31 for new Perplexity Pro subscribers.
  • It is limited to one redemption per PayPal or Venmo account.
  • Users with PayPal accounts created after September 1 will have a 30-day waiting period before gaining access.

Mark Your Calendar for the PLAI Summit in September

Logo for the PLAI Summit featuring a stylized mountain with circuit lines branching across it, topped with a flag. Below the mountain, the text reads "PLAI Summit," with the "AI" incorporated into a smiling robot face.

Friday, September 19, 2025
9:00 am – 4:30 pm

Houston H. Harte Center for Teaching and Learning
@ Washington and Lee University

How do we decide when to press the AI button—and when not to?

The PLAI Summit is a full-day event bringing together educators, students, and professionals to explore one of the most urgent questions of our time: how do we use AI to extend human capability—without compromising what makes us human?

Through hands-on demos, thought-provoking discussions, and multidisciplinary exchange, we’ll dive into how AI is reshaping art, society, science, and learning. The goal isn’t just to showcase innovation—it’s to build a shared awareness of when and why we choose to use AI, and when we deliberately choose not to.

Join us in imagining a future where AI supports—not supplants—human curiosity, creativity, and care.

NEW! Helpful Resource to Boost Your Students’ Research Presentation Skills

Flat-style digital illustration of graphic design tools arranged on a teal background. The composition includes a computer monitor displaying an eye symbol, a keyboard, a drawing tablet, color swatches, a ruler, a notebook, a floppy disk, a smartphone, and various writing instruments, representing design and visual communication elements.

Looking for a way to help your students shine in their research presentations? The Visual Research Communication guide, crafted by the University Library, is a fantastic resource you can recommend to your classes.

This guide equips students with practical tools to create clear, compelling visuals—skills that will serve them well in coursework, conferences, and beyond.

We’d like to extend a special shout-out to the talented team behind this resource:

  • Renee Watson, Head of Research Service
  • Emily Cook, Research and Instruction Librarian
  • Jenny Carlos, Research Services Resident Librarian

Their hard work and expertise have made this guide an invaluable asset for our academic community.

Please take a moment to share this link with your students: https://libguides.wlu.edu/vis-research/. It’s an impactful way to support their growth as scholars and communicators.

To request a 15-minute in-class session about effective poster design, please contact library@wlu.edu.